> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.iqra.ca/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Why Toronto’s Muslim Community Must Step Up for Disability Rights
- URL: https://www.iqra.ca/2026/why-torontos-muslim-community-must-step-up-for-disability-rights/
- Published: 2026-11-16T16:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T16:00:00.000Z
- Description: When they ask the institutions with the most to give, they get a small donation, a polite referral, a one-time sponsorship or, in the case of mosques, an allowance to stand at the door with donation boxes.
- Author: Iqra
- Tags: Editor, Muneeb Nasir, Deen Support Services

*By Muneeb Nasir*

For years, advocates, families, and grassroots organizers have fought for a dignified home in Scarborough, the eastern suburb of Toronto where Muslims with disabilities can receive spiritually appropriate services. 

When they ask the institutions with the most to give, they get a small donation, a polite referral, a one-time sponsorship or, in the case of mosques, an allowance to stand at the door with donation boxes.

This isn't a shortage of money or goodwill. It's a habit of mind that treats disability as a cause for sympathy rather than a matter of justice.

### **The problem with pity**

Traditional charity puts the giver on top and the receiver below, expected to be grateful. 

Applied to disability, it makes people objects of sympathy and turns disability into a personal tragedy rather than a question of rights, access, and housing. It also assumes that those receiving help can't be trusted to direct it.

Advocates Rabia Khedr, the late Rafia Haniff-Cleofas, and Omaya Rakieh named this on DEEN Support Services' [*Pity Party Podcast*](https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLESAC1SLLum8DsqzFcpBvUAzaoh1ovW31&si=Do6l7Q8rt7Vzta-m&ref=iqra.ca), mocking a society happy to throw a pity party while leaving every barrier in place.

That mindset rewards giving that is easy, brief, and visible, like people with disabilities left at the mosque door collecting money for their own housing. 

The community feels generous while those who need a home do the asking. That isn't community support. It's a community outsourcing its responsibility to the people it claims to care about.

### **Care that decides for you**

Pity has a quieter cousin: paternalism. It says, "We know what's best for you," and sounds like protection but works as control.

Women and people with disabilities hear it constantly, often from people who mean well. 

Decisions about where they live and what they can handle get made in rooms they weren't invited into. Needing support is treated as lacking judgment, and women are welcomed in the kitchen but rarely at the board table. Women with disabilities face both.

Pity says they are to be felt sorry for; paternalism, that they are to be managed. Both agree they needn't be asked, which is why so many programs and housing plans designed for people with disabilities miss what they need.

Our own tradition starts elsewhere. Islam holds every adult individually accountable before God, presuming a moral agent with a mind and will of their own. Dignity means the right to make choices, including imperfect ones, with support rather than substitution.

As the disability rights movement says, *nothing about us without us*. Those who need a home should help design and govern it. Anything less is charity wearing a better coat.

### **Justice is always somewhere else**

When disaster strikes overseas, we move fast. Appeals go out and millions arrive within days. Then someone with a disability stands at our own door asking for a home, and it needs a board meeting.

It isn't only disability. People sleep outside in winter, seniors age alone, families skip meals, and we answer with the same pity: a nod, a small donation, a prayer.

Distant injustice is clear, urgent, and asks nothing of how we run our own institutions. **Injustice at home implicates us.**

Islamic teaching calls meeting essential community needs *fard kifayah*, a collective obligation: when enough people take it on, the duty lifts from the rest; when no one does, the whole community answers for it. A home for people with disabilities is not a favour we may grant or withhold. It is a duty we share until someone fulfills it.

### **From charity to solidarity**

We must move from **charity to solidarity**, and from **pity to rights**, by asking harder questions:

- Not *"What can we spare?"* but *"How do we share our resources so everyone has a place to live?"*
- Not *"How do we help these unfortunate people?"* but *"What keeps our neighbours from living independently?"*

A home isn't just where care is delivered. It's where people make their own choices, build relationships, and take part as full citizens.

### **A call to those with resources**

To faith leaders, professional associations, business groups and donors: **you have mobilized millions for injustice far away. Why not at your own door?**

The next time someone with a disability stands at the mosque door with a flyer, ask why they are the ones collecting. Stop outsourcing the work to the people who need the result. When you act, speak to women and people with disabilities and design teams that shape the answer.

Pity comforts the giver. Solidarity gives people rights and dignity. 

A home for people with disabilities isn't extraordinary generosity; it's the baseline test of whether our professed values of compassion, equity, and inclusion mean anything.

DEEN Support Services: [https://www.deensupportservices.ca/scarborough-home](https://www.deensupportservices.ca/scarborough-home?ref=iqra.ca)